While it’s fun to talk about the movie moments that infuriate us when it comes to the Harry potter movies, there are at least a few handfuls of iconic book moments that the movies are absolutely right about. Sometimes it’s because they stayed true to the text and brought the moment to life straight from the page, and sometimes it’s because they took the essence of the scene and created a visual yet better.
Check out these 10 examples of scenes the Harry Potter movies pulled off perfectly.
Dumbledore’s fight against Voldemort in “Order of the Phoenix”
While this scene wasn’t exactly beaten to beat what happened between the book’s two powerful wizards, it was an incredibly compelling scene and exemplified exactly what she intended to do. Dumbledore (Michel gambon) is the strongest wizard, even with all the dark magic Voldemort (Ralph fiennes) Has at hand, but barely. We have not seen much of the iconic fountain of the book, but the parts of the water and the heat of battle shows how each of these wizards use magic in his way, but both have a power greater than that anyone else of age. It really would not have gone better, at least in the eyes of the fan.
Harry sees Hogwarts for the first time in “The Sorcerer’s Stone”
Christopher Colombus shot an extremely faithful adaptation of Harry potter and the sorcerer’s stone, hitting all of the biggest beats from the start of the series as near to perfection as any fan could hope for. One of those moments would be the early years’ journey across the lake, giving them their first glimpse of the castle, and a lingering spyglass as small boats glide gently through the waters of the Black Lake to their new home away from home. them, Hogwarts. From the Hogwarts Express to the gates of the Great Hall, the whole sequence works flawlessly. With Hagrid (Robbie coltrane) doing his part to bring in the youth, acting as steward of the new first grade class.
This scene of Hermione and Bellatrix in ‘Deathly Hallows: Part 1’
While the first two scenes on this list were exciting in one way or another, this one is iconic for an entirely different reason. Since Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows is said of Harry (Daniel radcliffe), we don’t see what horrors take place between Hermione and Bellatrix in the book, and there’s not much Hermione is willing to divulge afterwards. Since the movies aren’t hampered by the books’ closed third-person storytelling, we can leave Harry and Ron (Rupert grint) in the basement with Dobby and get a glimpse of what Bellatrix is doing to Hermione. It’s a dark scene, but it’s an important moment for Hermione, as well as Ron, as her instinct to protect her shifts into high gear.
Dobby’s introduction to ‘Chamber of Secrets’
A little like the sorcerer’s stone, Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets faithfully adapts the book in a way that later films certainly don’t. Dobby’s introduction is as close to perfect as it gets. While the Dursleys entertain downstairs, Harry tries to keep Dobby’s noise to a minimum. When that fails and Dobby escapes downstairs, Harry follows him, only for Dobby to break a cake over the guests’ heads as a last ditch effort to keep Harry from going to Hogwarts. A truly memorable and well-suited scene.
Professor McGonagall sends Hogwarts statues into battle in “Deathly Hallows: Pt 2”
McGonagall (Maggie Smith) very rarely let down her guard, mainly because she is a good British educator and headmistress. She knows there are serious issues to be resolved in the running of the school and has dedicated her life to helping prepare children for life outside of school. In this final chapter, McGonagall has a moment when the childlike wonder of fully realized magic overwhelms her unmoved British demeanor, and it’s a highlight for just about any Harry Potter fan. Seeing a book moment like this come to life on film, and with a very special quality, that’s exactly why it’s so special to see books adapted for the screen. Readers knew McGonagall had to use a rare spell, but moviegoers could see the absolute glee on her face.
Harry and Ron visit Aragog in ‘Chamber of Secrets’
Between enter the danger and the importance of the encounter with Aragog Harry and Ron, the film, once again, succeeded. We see Aragog welcome these “friends of Hagrid ‘among them, answer their questions and tell them what they most need to know. This is when his true nature Acromantula climaxed, and he sows his children on the couple of young heroes. The film manages so well that scene. The seriousness with which Aragog turns against boys, the coarseness of the clearing covered with paintings he calls home, this time to film seems straight out of the book.
The Christmas ball in “Goblet of fire”
The imagination is infinite, and therefore reading is a wonderful hobby, but sometimes our minds can not fully grasp the complexity of something like the Yule Ball. It is one thing to imagine the great hall decorated for a formal occasion, even considering the possibilities of a magical setting, but another to see it covered from floor to ceiling in pure decadence. The scintillating beauty of the ball on the theme of winter comes to life on film sets the stage for an important frivolity in adolescents.
The second task in ‘Goblet of Fire’
While the adaptation of the first and last tasks of the Triwizard Tournament in Harry Potter the Goblet of Fire film leaves something to be desired, the second task is a fairly faithful narrative, but with the limitless visuals that only a film can provide. Imagining the sirens, the vastness of the Black Lake and the predicament of the four captives is one thing, watching the whole event unfold is another. This task was very well represented on the film, showing fans not only the seriousness of the business, but the danger of the challenge. Although there are many things that Goblet of Fire is completely wrong, it is not one of them. The second task was well represented.
School mourns Dumbledore in “The Half-Blood Prince”
There are a number of true-to-the-book moments on this list. It is not one of them. There is no scene in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince in which the school gathers in the courtyard to mark the passing of Dumbledore. However, this moment manages to illustrate both the gravity of what this particular death means for everyone involved, as well as the dedication and love this school has for its principal. It’s not hard to imagine this practice of sending sparks from your wand into the night sky being used as a display of devotion throughout the magical community. He honors the dead by displaying the light they have brought to the world one last time, and he certainly binds the students of Hogwarts together at this most difficult time.
Unveiling of Peter Pettigrew in “The Prisoner of Azkaban”
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban is chock-full of changes in her adaptation, but there’s one scene that feels so right that it doesn’t matter if it’s one hundred percent faithful to her adaptation or not. When Sirius (Gary oldman), Lupine (David Thewlis) and Peter Pettigrew (Timothy Spall), the three remaining Marauders, come face to face for the first time since the deaths of James and Lily, the scene sings with emotion and revenge. Everything in this scene, from Sirius’ vehemence to avenge the death of his best friend, to Harry’s plan to prevent Sirius from remaining an outlaw in favor of handing over Pettigrew to the Dementors, is perfect for the time being. There might be a detail or two that stray from the book, but absolutely nothing that could change the gravity of this moment has been overlooked.
Do you miss the magical world of Hogwarts? Here are 15 movies to quench your wizarding appetite.
About the Author